plan 211Water System, Latrines, Fuel-Efficient Stoves, and Health/Hygiene Education: Payacuca, Nicaragua

Summary

[Funding secured for water, need only for funds for the latrine] Install electric powered pump gravity distribution system; reforest watershed; train in hygiene practices and sustainable environmental practices; install 143 latrines; construct 15 fuel eff

Background

This project will benefit the community of Payacuca, located in the Terrabona Muncipality of the department of Matagalpa. This community is too small and remote to receive assistance from other organizations.

Payacuca is a Spanish-speaking Mestizo community that lives in extreme poverty surviving on less than $50 a month. They depend on subsistence agriculture and livestock activities for their livelihood, or work as day laborers in neighboring regions. Although they have a primary school, it is quite rudimentary without running water or bathrooms. Aside from the primary school, this community is highly disenfranchised and lacks access to all basic services (drinking water, sanitation, phones, hospitals, etc) except for electricity.

The current water sources for the community are artisanal water holes along the side of the river. These water holes are highly polluted as they are used for watering livestock, bathing, and washing clothes. As a result the water is not fit for human consumption. Currently, families must travel from 100 meters up to 1 kilometer to bring water to their houses.

The community also lacks adequate sanitation, as latrines are either non-existent or are in such a deteriorated condition so as to be unusable.

Location

Terrabona, Matagalpa, Nicaragua

Attachments

  • new_stov...
  • buckets.jpg
  • Memoria_...
  • Topog_LC...
  • Topograf...
  • BPN_budg...
  • 1 participant | show more

    Review process

    Rajesh Shah of Peer Water Exchange

    The fate of this application is somewhat tied El Porvenir's other application. Rather than making reviewers review 2 similar applications, we are reviewing only one. We realize that one is solar powered and this one is not. The cost/beneficiary is much better in this one so depending on those f...

    The fate of this application is somewhat tied El Porvenir's other application.

    Rather than making reviewers review 2 similar applications, we are reviewing only one.

    We realize that one is solar powered and this one is not. The cost/beneficiary is much better in this one so depending on those factors it is possible that this one may receive a better fate than the other one.

  • 1 participant | show more

    Initial assessment of proposed project by Rick McGowan

    Rick McGowan of Team Blue

    Payacuca Nicaragua - Porvenir Project In general – the proposal is reasonable in its description, but there are many missing issues that need to be addressed before any financing should be committed. See below (issues are not in any particular order of importance): Water Quality - Other than a brief description of the current source, th...

    Payacuca Nicaragua - Porvenir Project

    In general – the proposal is reasonable in its description, but there are many missing issues that need to be addressed before any financing should be committed. See below (issues are not in any particular order of importance):

    Water Quality - Other than a brief description of the current source, there appears to be no reference to water quality testing before or after construction. Who will do this and who will pay for it?

    Electricity Power – from where? Reliability? Who pays and how much? Who repairs (communities?)? Who trains operators, buys or provides spare parts and materials, electricity? Is there a relatively nearby source of materials and equipment for maintenance, repair, and expansion?

    Cost, Funding Sources, and Contributions– who pays for goods, materials, labor, training, etc. for system construction? It appears that community labor will be provided, but by who, and how much per family, and what tasks do they carry out? Digging trenches, hauling sand and pipes, etc. They should specify exactly what group(s) finance what aspects of the project.

    Technical Operations Staff and Training- Who trains and pays the trained technical people who will design, operate and maintain the system? Who provides engineering design, operational training, construction management, O&M follow-up?

    Gravity Flow Water Distribution – This apparently means a single main storage / collection tank with a gravity flow uphill source, or downhill source (groundwater, spring water, etc.) pumped up to villages with multiple tanks for gravity distribution? They need a better description of the system and who will design it, built it, maintain, get spare parts, etc.

    What kind of latrines? Who builds? Who pays? who de-sludges? 9 feet deep? That's a lot of shit. How do they de-sludge from that depth? Or do they just build new ones?

    Why the fuel efficient stoves? What kind, how much, who designs, etc.

    Why 1160 getting water and only 481 getting latrines? Financial, technical or promotion insufficiencies? They say that all beneficiaries receive training, so why not more latrines? Cash constraints? Unwillingness to pay, etc.?

    Where do the stove designs come from? Are they ground-tested? Who builds?

    If community is too provide ongoing repair and maintenance, who will train them to do this?

    Where do they get spare parts and the money to buy the spare parts?

    Why do they say that the community is too small for support from other organizations? For example, if 1160 people get access to improved water (check later to see if it is treated, distributed, pressurized, etc.

    Is the $50/month per family or person? It didn't appear to say. Probably per family.

    How do they collect funds for repairs, maintenance, expansion, water treatment, etc.?

    Who does the reforestation activities? Who trains and pays these people?

    In general, this seems to be a fairly reasonable proposal, but it is lacking in detail with regard to responsibilities, financing, planning, and O&M.

    By the way, I could not open the budget file because it was apparently mis-named as “xls.doc file. You should rename and re-post it to a common MS Word format.

  • 1 participant | show more

    Lynn Roberts of Agua Para La Salud (APLS)

    I have read the very detailed 71 page project description (in Spanish) of the Trinidad project proposal and find most of the questions above answered in that proposal to my satisfaction. If the proposal for this project is as detailed it should minimize some of the concern about the project. Is the Payacuca proposal available?

    I have read the very detailed 71 page project description (in Spanish) of the Trinidad project proposal and find most of the questions above answered in that proposal to my satisfaction. If the proposal for this project is as detailed it should minimize some of the concern about the project. Is the Payacuca proposal available?

  • 3 participants | show more

    Lynn Roberts of Agua Para La Salud (APLS)

    Do you have a water system design and materials list for this project you could post on the application?

    Do you have a water system design and materials list for this project you could post on the application?

    • Rajesh Shah of Blue Planet Network

      Can you briefly note down some differences between the 2 projects? - regarding the electricity source? - you mention pumps? do you need more than one? - have you designed the storage capacity and pump hp? Am inviting Lynn of APS and Rick of Team Blue. No compulsion to review, but they are interested and experienced in this area. ...

      Can you briefly note down some differences between the 2 projects?

      - regarding the electricity source?
      - you mention pumps? do you need more than one?
      - have you designed the storage capacity and pump hp?

      Am inviting Lynn of APS and Rick of Team Blue. No compulsion to review, but they are interested and experienced in this area.

      East Meets West have done nearly a hundred projects like this and maybe Rick can be of help, having been close to many of them.

    • Rob Bell of El Porvenir

      Lynn, Added a couple of design docs I found. Pretty busy this week, will look for more and answer some more questions tomorrow. Rob

      Lynn,

      Added a couple of design docs I found. Pretty busy this week, will look for more and answer some more questions tomorrow.
      Rob